@kettlevoid This is basically the plot of Umineko and quite a few characters in particular.
@wistahe what does it talk about?
@kettlevoid There's a bunch of closed room murders of the protagonist's family on a remote island and a witch claims to have done it, but the protagonist claims witches do not exist so they have a logic battle over the true nature of the crimes. Over time the plot becomes more and more complex with more and more supernatural characters showing up whose objectives regarding solving the crimes differ quite a bit.
@wistahe ...and did the witch do it or not? And also, supernatural character, but are the crimes themselves done supernaturally?
@kettlevoid That's a good question, you'll have to read it to find out!
@wistahe wait it's a manga? I thought it was a visual novel
@kettlevoid It's a visual novel, but there is a manga too which I've heard is pretty good. Don't watch the anime.
@wistahe Oh great! Don't worry, i don't watch anime.